DNFSB: ‘Significant Issues’ in AMWTP Safety Basis

Brian Bradley
WC Monitor
12/4/2015

There have been "significant issues" with the safety basis for the Advanced Mixed Waste Treatment Project (AMWTP) in Idaho, leading to “underestimating the likelihood and consequences” of some accident scenarios, according to the Defense Nuclear Facilities Safety Board. This may have brought about inadequacies in the selection and classification of employee and public safety controls, DNFSB Chairwoman Joyce Connery wrote in a Nov. 23 letter to Assistant Energy Secretary for Environmental Management Monica Regalbuto.

Among the issues DNFSB staff members identified in a recent review of AMWTP is that the accident analysis within the facility’s documented safety analysis (DSA) factored in too few gallons of fossil fuel in evaluating the consequences of a significant fossil fuel fire in the Idaho National Laboratory’s transuranic waste storage facilities. The DSA accident analysis assumes 40 gallons of fossil fuel, instead of the 200 gallons allowed in the TRU Storage Area (TSA) Retrieval Enclosure and other TRU storage buildings, according to the DNFSB report. 

The board also found that while the south side of AMWTP houses a 45,000-gallon propane storage tank, the north side contains a 30,000-gallon tank, and the complex possesses a 12,000-gallon propane delivery (refueling) truck, the Energy Department’s Office of Environmental Management and/or AMWTP contractor Idaho Treatment Group have not developed any “credited” safety structures, systems, and components, or specific administrative controls, for accidents involving any of the three structures.

“We understand that the DOE Idaho Operations Office is undertaking actions to resolve our concerns,” the letter states. “The Board’s staff will continue to monitor these efforts to improve the safety basis development, approval, and implementation processes at AMWTP and other defense nuclear facilities at INL.”

An EM spokesperson said the Idaho Field Office and ITG acted quickly to respond to the IG’s findings. "DOE-ID and the AMWTP contractor immediately took the appropriate actions and have submitted the necessary changes to the AMWTP Safety Basis documents to resolve the concerns identified earlier by the DNFSB staff’s review that were included in this letter,” the spokesperson wrote in an email last week. “The comments contained in the Board’s staff review will be used to further improve the safety basis development and implementation at the Idaho site."

In This Issue

More on This Topic


WIPP representatives outline plans for nearly six-month outage in 2027

The Department of Energy’s Waste Isolation Pilot Plant plans (WIPP) currently plans to begin a nearly six-month outage for waste hoist upgrades in July 2027, with work expected to finish in early January 2028, officials said during a Nov. 4 community forum.

The work will include upgrades to the waste hoist control and electrical systems, repairs to the shaft sump and refurbishment of related hoisting equipment. The project is part of WIPP’s longer-term infrastructure improvements outlined in DOE 2021-2031 strategic plan. 

DOE’s Carlsbad Field Office in New Mexico and WIPP’s Bechtel-led prime have been discussing the 2027 outage for some time. WIPP is the nation’s only deep underground disposal site for defense-related transuranic waste. 

The usual January maintenance period has been shifted and extended to accommodate the work. Salado Isolation Mining Contractors Deputy Program Manager Ryan Flynn said the schedule was developed in coordination with generator sites over the past year, taking their shipping preferences and contractor availability into account.

DOE and WIPP are coordinating with various DOE generator sites to reduce waste inventories at their facilities before the outage. Officials said waste generated during the work would be stored at the origin locations. Under current WIPP permit requirements, the repository can also store limited quantities of contact-handled transuranic mixed waste in its waste handling building for up to 60 days.

During fiscal 2026, ended Sept. 30, WIPP received 306 shipments, exceeding its annual  target by six, according to its online slide presentation. The number of transuranic waste shipments coming from Los Alamos National Laboratory amounted to 116 during the past fiscal year. 

DOE and the New Mexico Environment Department are continuing to negotiate a WIPP permit modification that could prioritize more shipments from Los Alamos.

Video of the meeting is available online. 

In This Issue

More on This Topic